Challenger Sales method : 5 mistakes to avoid.

Challenger Sales is the most innovative sales methodology since Solution Selling. Oddly enough, it is sometimes criticized or berated.

Some detractors argue that it merely reformulates established sales principles that belong to the ABC of selling. That is why we demystify the approach.

Some question the foundation of the Challenger sales journey: it starts with the definition of what makes you unique, which must be leveraged to offer a different and irrefutable perspective to your customers. Piece of cake!

The main problem is not the Challenger Sales methodology itself but the misconceptions and stereotypes surrounding it. Here are five reasons we have identified with our customers and prospects why the Challenger Sales approach fails.

Reason 1: poor fit.

The depth and breadth of the methodology may be a challenge for your sales organization.

In a nutshell, some of our customers use a sledgehammer to crack a nut. Lured by the promises of outstanding performance and the advice from consulting firms know of Challenger what they found on the web, they ignore:

• The extent of the initial thinking on differentiation inherent in the method.
• The ability of their sales force to absorb the approach.

Then comes the temptation of the shortcut: pack your bag for two days of forced march training! Consequence ? Jaw dropping salespeople who give up after a few weeks of putting into practice poorly mastered concepts. Not all sales rep profiles are able to cope with the learning challenges posed by Challenger Sales.

Reason 2: no plan, no change.

The Challenger Sales method must be implemented as a project, with a strong emphasis on change management.

The problem is not that Challenger is better suited for selling solutions or products: it works effectively for both. Challenger is a process that begins with defining what makes you unique, ideally focusing on the decision criteria that are undervalued by your customers and that you are the only one to offer.

Before delving into the method, it is crucial to conduct an in-depth analysis of your market positioning, your unique selling points, and the decision criteria of your customers. Without this preliminary step, your sales reps may be equipped with innovative concepts, and might perform better. However, you will only reap small, short-term benefits from the Challenger implementation.

Reason 3: poor content.

Your content may match your unique selling points but may not drive change.

Challenger sales means primarily adopting a different way to present. Sales presentations must be redesigned to respect a specific pattern: establishing credibility, delivering commercial insights, and confronting customers with a challenge they had never thought of before. Then, you should introduce yourself as the best alternative to solve this challenge. So far so good.

The main issue lies in marketing content. What we observe with our customers is, at best, a redesign of their existing content to highlight the business impact of their solution. There is a lack of agnostic and disruptive content—no new perspectives that make them stand out, generate surprise, or even instill a sense of urgency. This kind of content is essential to make customers rethink their approach and address problems in innovative ways.

Additionally, there is an overemphasis on thought leadership. Nothing that generates a change of mental model and triggers action. That is precisely the hallmark of a successful Challenger sales approach.

Reason 4: tailoring or targeting.

There is a confusion between tailoring and Mobilizers’ management.

Sales reps are often caught between the Mobilizer principle, a key component of the Challenger Sales approach, and the need to personalize sales messaging for each stakeholder involved in the decision-making process, as advocated by other sales methodologies.

Challenger Sales is supposed to solve the problem of multiple decision-makers specific to complex sales by detecting and adapting to different profiles : the Go-Getter, the Skeptic, and the Teacher. Personalization is supposed to jeopardize the creation of the consensus necessary for collective decision-making.

On the other hand, all sales methods, from Solution Selling to Target Account Selling, emphasize the importance of addressing the needs and concerns of each stakeholder. The harsh reality of complex sales reminds us of this imperative as well.

We have a strong opinion on this: you must do both. You must start with personal value drivers and then shift the focus from a “me” to “we” perspective. The famous “What’s in it for me” (WIIFM) must give way to the company greater good. Hence, the need to revamp the marketing approach.

Reason 5: assertiveness.

Salespeople are lost between passivity and aggressiveness.

How can I position myself as a trusted partner to my client while simultaneously creating constructive tension? Constructive tension involves challenging the client’s assumptions in a way that encourages new thinking and solutions. Without proper practice and coaching, there is a significant risk that some salespeople may mismanage this balance, damaging the client relationship or failing to drive meaningful engagement.

This issue is compounded by the fact that sales managers often lack the resources or training to change their own behaviors.

We have attended coaching and forecasting sessions where managers cling to their old habits, focusing too much on controlling adherence to the sales process. There is insufficient emphasis on coaching reps to develop a unique perspective, employ techniques for taking control, and ask the probing questions that are central to the Challenger approach.

No, Challenger Sales implementation is neither a bed of roses, nor a guarantee of success. The approach is first for complex deals. Do you sell a product? It can work too if you focus on what is adaptable to your organization and manage the approach as a project. Not a theoretical training to an umpteenth sales method which content will be forgotten after two weeks or abandoned at the first customer objection.

Stuck in Challenger Sales and curious to know more? Discover how we debunk the Challenger Sales myth.

Contact us on Bold & Sharp. Follow us about Bold d& Sharp.

Think. Good Selling.